Harry Potter VS. Narnia

[cyberg100]

So Yeah I want your view.

 

[Skul]

I love Narnia better, because at least in Narnia, all the witches and dark people die. IN Harry Potter, he is studying to actually become one.

 

[Gondor Knight of Narnia]

yeah. I think Harry Potter's uchy. Narnia's much better.

(I like LotR better than both though...)

 

[Skul]

I actually like Eragon and STar Wars better. Though I'm anxious for Narnia 2 to come out.

 

[EveningStar]

It's funny...the title of this thread conjures up so many funny mental images.

First off Harry Potter with a bright white face having his wand cut in half by Eustace at the Battle of the Ford at Beruna... Can you say Experio?

Next I see him in a turban, with the same hair cut and glasses but also a handlebar moustache and goatee, as Rabadash. "Oh Susie-Q, won't you be my Snooky Wooky? By the Seven Towers of Bolistan, you are the sugar in my tea!"

 

[-Daughter of Eve-]

Oh..this is hard..I've been a Harry Potter fan just as long as I've been a Narnia fan...I do really love them both,but I must say *sorry Harry!* that I like Narnia better.The magic,love and power of Narnia is just more...um...MAGICAL than Harry Potter could ever be.

 

[Skul]

Yeah. To avoid the risk of being banned from the site, I have to say that Narnia is better. At least those books have great endings.

 

[-Daughter of Eve-]

Indeed,they have great endings.One thing the Harry Potter books DON'T have (at least the last one).

 

[Skul]

In Narnia, every ending is happy, and the Last Battle is the happiest ending of all, even if it is sad.

 

[-Daughter of Eve-]

Indeed.It's happy and sad all at once.

 

[Georgie the Valient]

Whoa, happy and sad? For me it is equal.I've been an HP fan longer though

 

[Skul]

But at least Susan didn't die. If it were a true story, she could still be alive for all we know! But it's not, and she's not, and it isn't.

 

[-Daughter of Eve-]

I feel sorry for Susan,though.It must have been horrible for her to lose her family like that...but hopefully she met them all again when SHE died..

 

[Skul]

C.S. Lewis made it clear that she would never remember Narnia aggain. She was just too grown up.

 

[-Daughter of Eve-]

That's sad

 

[Skul]

Sad but true. She just wouldn't believe.

 

[Gondor Knight of Narnia]

C.S. Lewis made it clear that she would never remember Narnia aggain. She was just too grown up.

That doesn't mean she couldn't have been saved after and been in NEW Narnia when she died.

 

[EveningStar]

Yeah. To avoid the risk of being banned from the site, I have to say that Narnia is better. At least those books have great endings.

Funny. But to state the official line on this, people don't get banned from the site because they like some other book better than Chronicles of Narnia. Otherwise everyone that liked the Bible better would be banned, and that would cost us a few....

 

[Lila]

I like Narnia better. Period.

 

[Skul]

Yeah, but no book is more important than the Bible.