You sould. There's another version out now, with Neil Patrick Harris, but I don't know if there's gonna be a cast recording...I don't think so.
INTO THE WOODS!!! IS AMAZING!!! No, seriously, it's awesome. It's another Sondheim musical, and it's not based on any book. It's about your typical fairy tale characters (Little Red, Jack and the Beanstalk, Cinderella). In the first act, they all make a wish and get what they wish for, in the second act, it all goes wrong. It is very funny and the music is wonderful. Also, it has Bernadette Peters in it, which is always a plus. (I love that woman. She's gorgeous and very talented).