I LOVE Puddleglum!What creeped you out? I used to not like it, but now...I really don't know why i like it so much. I think it's because of Puddleglum.
I was creeped out by the underworld. I was over-sensitive, I know, but still... whenever I re-read the book, I remember how scared I got. xD
Also, parts of the book kinda depressed me, although I can't remember what they were now. xD I'm re-reading the whole series; I'll get to that one soon and perhaps change my mind about it.