Aslan or Gandalf or Dumbledore?

[Skandarluver4eva]

I got this idea from the narnia cast interview

ok so there is a three way fight between Aslan, Dumbledore, And Gandalf who would win?

 

[Skandarluver4eva]

I think it would be either Aslan or Gandalf

 

[Protagonist]

none of them.

 

[Skandarluver4eva]

what do you guys think?

 

[Friend of Aslan]

Aslan

Well... I think Aslan would win ... I like gandalf but I think Aslan (who represents Jesus) obviously needs too win lol

 

[Skandarluver4eva]

Well... I think Aslan would win ... I like gandalf but I think Aslan (who represents Jesus) obviously needs too win lol

that is super true!

 

[PrinceOfTheWest]

If you respect the various mythologies from which those characters came, it would have to be Aslan. Dumbledore was gifted but very much a human being. Gandalf was an incarnated Maia, or high spiritual being (something like an angel, but not quite). Aslan is the Son of the Emperor Over Sea; uncreated, all powerful, and eternal.

No real contest there.

 

[Skandarluver4eva]

If you respect the various mythologies from which those characters came, it would have to be Aslan. Dumbledore was gifted but very much a human being. Gandalf was an incarnated Maia, or high spiritual being (something like an angel, but not quite). Aslan is the Son of the Emperor Over Sea; uncreated, all powerful, and eternal.

No real contest there.

very good point Prince

 

[KathrynJanewayChakotay]

I think Aslan hands down

 

[King Of The Hallows]

Aslan HANDS DOWN. Dumbledore cant touch aslan.

 

[Protagonist]

I hate to admit it but I really hate Aslan.

 

[King Of The Hallows]

I hate to admit it but I really hate Aslan.

You hate ASLAN

 

[Eärendil the Mariner]

Aslan, hands down. Gandalf is more of an Angel when compared to Aslan, because he isn't the Supreme Ruler of Middle-Earth (Illuvatar is). I know little of Dumledore, but I'm sure Aslan could take him.

 

[Jack of Blades]

Aslan > Gandalf > Dumbledore

PoTW put it better. Aslan is basically our Jesus, Gandalf is an angel, Dumbledore is a human.

 

[Telcontargirl]

Aslan will always win because he's the only sinless one.

 

[Lila]

Pshaw. We all already know who wins.

Aslan = Jesus. I'm pretty sure Gandalf is like... I dunno... a disciple? Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore is a dedicated fan. haha.

 

[Ck-Oakenshield]

All of them. I learned a lot from those 3

 

[Frodosgurl]

Aslan or Gandalf!

 

[Frodosgurl]

I hate to admit it but I really hate Aslan.

10thingy

 

[EveningStar]

Aslan would win, paws down.