Lucy: defending her truths

MrBob

Well-known member
I was just thinking earlier today about how much Lucy had to stand up for her beliefs in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.

In the beginning of LWW, she does the seemingly impossible by entering another strange world merely by walking into a wardrobe and meeting a strange creature with whom she visited for a few hours, having tea, conversing, and nearly being kidnapped by him. Coming out, she tried to tell her siblings what happened, but having been gone for only a moment and going back to see that the wardrobe was just a plain one, no one could believe her. She never let go of that experience she knew to be true in the face of her siblings insistence (and sometimes cruel jokes) that it was just her imagination. In the book, she even considered that things would be easier if she admitted (if falsely) that she was joking, but she could not do that as it would be lying, something she did not do.

Her story was challenged even moreso when Edmund, after having found Narnia, told Peter and Susan that he was just pretending with Lucy. She stuck with her story (the truth) that she had visited this strange land despite all evidence to the contrary, including the denial of the one person who could validate her story.

Not once, however, did her faith in her story waver. She knew she was right. I think it was this defense of what she knew to be right that helped to make her the most ardent disciple of Aslan. Defending your own truths against everyone else who either doesn't want to believe you or simply doesn't believe you can either make you question yourself or make you more ardent in your beliefs of the truth. And this is why she was known as the Valiant. She was already showing it before she knew she could become queen.

MrBob
 
Great thoughts, MrBob! That's why, despite loving all characters, I've always been fond of Lucy. She has the childlike faith for Narnia and Aslan from the beginning, and the others need to learn it better before holding tight to it.
 
I was just thinking earlier today about how much Lucy had to stand up for her beliefs in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.

In the beginning of LWW, she does the seemingly impossible by entering another strange world merely by walking into a wardrobe and meeting a strange creature with whom she visited for a few hours, having tea, conversing, and nearly being kidnapped by him. Coming out, she tried to tell her siblings what happened, but having been gone for only a moment and going back to see that the wardrobe was just a plain one, no one could believe her. She never let go of that experience she knew to be true in the face of her siblings insistence (and sometimes cruel jokes) that it was just her imagination. In the book, she even considered that things would be easier if she admitted (if falsely) that she was joking, but she could not do that as it would be lying, something she did not do.

Her story was challenged even moreso when Edmund, after having found Narnia, told Peter and Susan that he was just pretending with Lucy. She stuck with her story (the truth) that she had visited this strange land despite all evidence to the contrary, including the denial of the one person who could validate her story.

Not once, however, did her faith in her story waver. She knew she was right. I think it was this defense of what she knew to be right that helped to make her the most ardent disciple of Aslan. Defending your own truths against everyone else who either doesn't want to believe you or simply doesn't believe you can either make you question yourself or make you more ardent in your beliefs of the truth. And this is why she was known as the Valiant. She was already showing it before she knew she could become queen.

MrBob

Very true mr Bob Lucy was strong enough and had Faith enough to stand up for what she believed in no matter what that did make her valiant you are right she never compromised
 
I agree, this is one of the reasons Lucy is my favorite character, too. She is broken-hearted when her bros and sis don't believe her, but she doesn't give in just to make them be nice to her again. She remains broken hearted, but sticks to her guns. Very admirable.
 
Yes, i always did admire the fact that even when she was being teased and people were not believing her, she held onto what she knew was the truth, despite it all.Luckily for Lucy, the otherse eventually found out she was right, but in real life, this doesn't always happen, unfortunately, and sometimes you're forced to realize that sometimes it's enough just for u to know your right.
 
Yes, i always did admire the fact that even when she was being teased and people were not believing her, she held onto what she knew was the truth, despite it all.Luckily for Lucy, the otherse eventually found out she was right, but in real life, this doesn't always happen, unfortunately, and sometimes you're forced to realize that sometimes it's enough just for u to know your right.
Good point, Catherine. This is the case when you stand up for some principle because of your faith in Christ, yet everyone around you feels there is no problem with violating this principle, whatever it is. You can be left standing along, the only one not to go along ... and yet nothing dire happens to those folks who did it. The only "reward" you have is knowing that you kept your faith. It can be tough.
 
It bears noticing that Lucy was not believing without any evidence; it was just that the very real evidence she had witnessed was outside the knowledge of others. Christians do not have to fall back on "I believe it because it makes me feel good;" we do have evidence.
 
Exactly, people think it's stupid when we believe due to personal evidence rather than external. Lucy was convinced, because she'd seen absolutely refuteable evidence of Narnia. Just because she couldn't bring physical evidence wouldn't stop her believing.
 
Back
Top