Matthew McFadyen or Collin Firth as Mr. Darcy

[music girl]

Personnally I prefer Matthew McFadyen to Colin Firth but I want to know what you think

 

[the Large Voice]

How can I ever decide?!!!! They both do a wonderful job...

 

[inkspot]

Colin Firth, all the way. No contest.
Dreamy Mr. Darcy.

 

[the Large Voice]

I love Matthew Macfadyen in the 2005 version, but Colin Firth's "Mr. Darcy" is like the book character, so I'll go with Colin.

 

[~Lava~]

By the way, there is already a thread like this on Wood between the Worlds, though it is not specifically about Mr. Darcy, that is where this thread belongs. That being said: (You know what I am about to say Bethie) COLIN FIRTH IS THE BEST MR. DARCY EVER!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[abbyluvswilliam]

COLLIN FIRTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DO DOUBT ABOUT IT! HE IS Fitwilliam Darcy!!!!

 

[~Lava~]

I completely agree.

 

[mrstumnus99]

Yeah Collin Firth is Mr. Darcy. Matthew does a pretty good job though but he's nothing compared to Collin.

 

[eggnog]

dont know

so i really think eggnog should have done it

 

[~Lava~]

Oh, shut up Shawn.

 

[Samwise Gamgee]

Oh Colin Firth hands down, he was soooooooo Darcey in P&P.

 

[music girl]

I feel out numbered on my own thread . By the way Matthew McFadyen is so HOTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!! Hotter than Collin Firth SOOOO!!!! DREAMY!!!!!!

 

[abbyluvswilliam]

Sorry that ur outnumbered! We all love you anyway...haha!

 

[~Lava~]

Lizzie, as evidenced by everyone who has posted, it is very clear that not many share your opinion.

 

[the Large Voice]

I didn't vote for "hotness", I chose Colin Firth for the best Mr. Darcy according to the book. There's no way I can decide which guy is "hotter"...


---->*hehehe*

 

[Lady Theresa]

Colin Firth all the Way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Not only is he the HOTTER Mr. Darcy, but he is the BETTER Mr. Darcy!!!!!!!! He is more accurate to Mr. Fitzwilliam Darcy in the book. And on over all Hottness you have to give him an A+!!!!!!!!!!

 

[butterflychick]

hhmmmmm. matthew McFadyen

 

[Samwise Gamgee]

To me 'hot'ness of a person dosen't matter, it is How they act the charaters. Collin Ferth just added more to Darcey than Mat.

 

[Lady Theresa]

I believe I said that, but I also said that Colin Firth is just hotter than Matthew!!

 

[~Lava~]

bc you cannot base your decision on prejudice from LotD or from just looking at a picture side by side. I know for a fact that you have not even watched the old movie and you barely watched the new movie as you told me yourself. That is why you need to come to our house and watch them both. How about a sleepover?