my last post on this subject, please reply

R

reepipuddleglumweather

New member
real narnia after life again

please read
i get this amazing feeling when watching the moviethere is this sense of epicness, and wonder
there are so many things you could do in narnia , but all of them require things that you cant do in the real narnia. adventure, i think must inclide some sort of danger or peril, what kind of adventure can u have in the real nanria?
all of my questions about narnia, even its wars have been answered except the real narnia
so sumone
have pity and take the time to answer the questions below

is there winter in the real naqrtnia?
is there extrem cold or heat?
is there bad weather?
do u have to eat and drink?
if u walked for days would you become exahausted ?
can u get lost?can u cough or get sick or anythign of that nature?
can u bruise or cut yourself?
what idf u took a knife and slashed it across your hand would it bleed?
are lifting rocks heavy?
does fire burn your skin?

now THESE ARE THE MOST IMPORTANT QUESTIONS
why do people carry swords?
can u feel free will in the real narnia? can u feel hate towards another. example a hedgehog dint want a a faun inside his houseon a stormy day, because he dint llike the faun. is the hedgehog required to let him in?

does everybody know everybody in the real narnia? or do u always meet new people?
what do u do in the real nanria, normal life?
who rules in the real nanria?
is there more than one real narnia? layers?



ILOVEANNAPOPPLEWELL[love1]
Rise Sir Peter Wolfs Bane: Knight of Narnia [royal]
 
Note that this is all guess work. I am thinking and trying to come up with the answer that seems most likely based on my small knowledge.
These answers are based on these assumptions:
1. Narnia is comparable to heaven except it is for Narnians.
2. Anything can happen but because it is perfect only good happens.
3. Anything that brings about joy that isn't sinful (such as listening to an awsome song or playing a game or climbing a mountain) can be done.
4. Its not a matter of what you can do, it is a matter of what you would do.

Q: Is there winter in the real narnia?
A: Winter is can be very enjoyable. It would have to be there.
Q: Is there extreme cold or heat?
A: Extreme cold and heat as in uncomfortable, no... however if one could find a way to enjoy it...
Q: Is there bad weather?
A: There is no bad weather. All weather is looked upon as good... it is impossible to not like the weather because it will always feel perfect to you.
Q: Do you have to eat and drink?
A: No, but I like to eat and drink (I'm sure I'm the only one lol :D ). So in my case I would eat and drink anyways.
Q: If you walked for days would you become exhausted?
A: Some people feel good when they are exhausted... like they have accomplished something... so you could become exhausted if you wanted but if you wanted to say sprint nonstop you could do that without becoming exhausted.
Q: Can you get lost?
A: I suppose if you wanted to you could get lost... I imagine being able to impose temporary limits on oneself so that you are always safe in the end but can make yourself helpless in someways temporarily.
Q: Can you get sick or anything of that nature?
A: Yes but only if you want to, and you could always get better... I can't imagine why anybody would want to be sick.
Q: Can you bruise or cut yourself?
A: Yes, you can do that without any harm being done, you can do that without it being painful... Although, again, what I don't see there being any source of motivation to do such a thing anyways.
Q: If you slashed a knife across you hand, would you bleed?
A: You could do it without bleeding (I think) but if you did it and wanted to bleed... (again no motivation I can see but hey whatever) you could always be alright in the end.
Q: When you lift rocks would they be heavy or would it be hard to lift them?
A: Some people enjoy lifting heavy things for fun. You could do it with out it being heavy (I think) but if you wanted to do it so that it feels really hard to do you could do that too. Some people (such as myself) enjoy things that are challenging and hard to do.
Q: Does fire burn your skin?
A: Yes or no, whichever you prefer. You could burn it without feeling any pain if you wanted. You could also light it on fire and have it lit without it burning I suppose.
Q: Why do people carry swords?
A: If you mean in the real narnia... I didn't know that they had swords but if they do, I suppose it would be merly for sport. When there is pain involved, it ceases from being a sport and becomes sick fun however many people today have fencing matches and all sorts of matches where nobody gets hurt and it is nothing but a match of skill. So any swords in the real narnia would be for fun, non...bad purposes.
Q: Do you have freewill in the real narnia?
A: Most certainly yes! However you won't be tempted to do bad things, so freewill can't bring about sin because you just won't sin.
Q: Can you feel hate towards others?
A: No. In the real narnia you are to mature to want to hate anybody. You could but you won't. Imagine this... if God is allpowerful can he sin? Of course God would never sin, he just won't. If he couldn't sin then he wouldn't be allpowerful so logically he must be able to but doesn't because he is perfect.
Q: Does everybody know everybody? Can you meet new people?
A: If you want to you can know everybody but meeting new people can be such a blessing. I would think if one day you didn't want to know everybody that you could just forget anybody and be able to meet them all over again.
Q: What is normal life like in the real narnia?
A: This answer is different for every individual. I would probably create all sorts of art such as music, games, and visual art. I would also spend time with other people. Have fun together, have fun by myself, have fun lots. I would put self imposed limits for many different reason. Limits make things interesting... for example, I have created computer games before, to make a game fun, you don't make it so that it is easy to win, you make it so that you have to try to win, it may be hard to win. If I started playing a game and there was a cheat code that just automatically made me win without even doing anything, that wouldn't be fun. Limits make things fun.
Q: Who rules in the real narnia?
A: Aslan, then whoever alsan wants to rule. However the position of ruling wouldn't be the same. In a perfect world government isn't required because the idea of government is to make the world perfect (this explains why good governments try to keep their citizens safe, why many governments try to give as much freedom as can be handled, some people who rule just try to make the world perfect for themselves. The idea is to make life as good as possible at least for somebody).
Q: Is there more than one real narnia (layers)?
A: Maybe... I can't think of a reason why not at the moment but I don't see why there would be either... I'm sorry but that is the one question I'll have to leave blank.

Ok I hoped these answers helped. I'm not sure they are all correct but I tryed my best to come up with the most likely answer that would be correct.
 
thanx a lot

i really appreciate ur answer it helped me alot

so ur saying it could be anything you wanted it to be
so if it was raining yo-u could just say stop rain and it would stop
if it was snowing and u stuck ur foot in the snow would EVERYBODY feel the cold

would there be calormen amabssodors, and ship trips, etc.
what about calormens can u make war against them ?

do u have those magic powers like in the book, of like climbing up waterfalls?

how could u not get lost
how would u know everybody u would have to have the experience of meeting them right?
 
You're basically asking what Heathen is like, and no-one can answer that. But Mejonny's answers make Heathen sound boring, and I'm sure--

No, I was going to say something I shouldn't....
 
Heaven is / Heaven isn't....

Heaven is a place where we will be very happy.

Heaven is not an amusement park.

Heaven is a place where the labor of our hands will be joyful and satisfying.

Heaven is not a retirement home.
 
I'd like to say again these answers are all based on how I imagine heaven which is of course extreme guess work. Heaven will not be boring. Imagine a nonsinful thing you like to do... you can do that there with the same limitations as you have here on earth if you want. You can also do that without the limitations. If God could create such a vast endless Universe I'm quite sure he could create an unending amount of and ways to do things in heaven. And remember the books imply that Aslan exists in our world too as somebody else. Since C. S. Lewis was a christian I'm pretty sure he was implying that Aslan was God.

Q: Could you be anything you wanted to be?
A: This is really hard to answer. You definately couldn't be God himself, although I have often wondered if in heaven it would be ok to create life. I know I would create life if I could. You wouldn't actually become anything but you could make it as if you were something else. Like you would still be yourself but If you wanted to be a dog for a while I should think you could turn yourself into a dog... although you would always be able to become yourself again so you really were always yourself but it was as if you were a dog... does that make sense lol.
Q: If it was raining could you just tell it to stop.
A: Yes. Christians believe we can do that already. (Although this requires a great deal of faith... I don't bother trying because it is not important anyways). Anything is possible with God. Jesus Disciples were humans and performed the same miracles as Jesus except coming back to life on earth.
Q: If it was snowing and you stuck your foot in the snow, would everybody feel the cold?
A: Not necessarily. They could (I think).
Q: Would there be calorman ambassadors and ship trips?
A: Yes, although ambassadors wouldn't serve the same purpose because they wouldn't need to worry about war or anything of that nature. Yes there would be ship trips!
Q: Can you make war against the calormans?
A: There will be no war. Although contests of skill are always fun. I suppose if sometime the calormans and narnians wanted to have a contest in a game that used the same skills as those of war that would be the closest thing you would get.
Q: Do you have those magic powers from the book?
A: Yes, if you wanted to fall down a water fall though you could do that too.
Q: How could you not get lost?
A: If you wanted to get lost you could but there would be no such thing as being lost forever. The only way you could get lost is to allow yourself to get lost. This is extreme guess but I would think to get lost you could impose mind limitations on yourself for a time so that it is possible to get lost.
Q: How could you know everybody? Wouldn't you have to meet them first?
A: You wouldn't have to meet them first and could know them without meeting them. Although for enjoyment you could not know somebody and experiance meeting them.
 
alright thanx mejonny

so what u think is that in real narnia you can basically do ANYTHING
you can do anythign you want?

so i b asically get it if that is true

describe a day what would a typical narnian do.

ok two more very important questions

if u do have free will, can u get mad at some body, or dis agre with them, hateful thoughts etc.

lewis mentioned layers of nanria, so is there more than one real narnia? this is kind of disturbing to me , i think there should be just one narnia.

ok one more how many people are in the real narnia?

ide apprecitae answers to these questions
 
reepipuddleglumweather said:
so what u think is that in real narnia you can basically do ANYTHING
you can do anythign you want?
Click to expand...
Yup, as long as it doesn't hurt someone else.

so i b asically get it if that is true
Click to expand...
It is.

describe a day what would a typical narnian do.
Click to expand...
Anything s/he wanted, and there isn't such a thing as a typical day, each day is unique and different.

ok two more very important questions
Click to expand...

if u do have free will, can u get mad at some body, or dis agre with them, hateful thoughts etc.
Click to expand...
FOR THE LAST TIME no!!

lewis mentioned layers of nanria, so is there more than one real narnia? this is kind of disturbing to me , i think there should be just one narnia.
Click to expand...
Well, there isn't, there are layers.

ok one more how many people are in the real narnia?
Click to expand...
[Sarcasm] Exactly 12,345 [/Sarcasm] How am I supposed to know every single narnian that's died??

ide apprecitae answers to these questions
Click to expand...
Answered.
 
Last edited:
Jimmy pretty much said the same as what I would have said.
You can get mad at somebody but you won't. You can have hateful thoughts but you just won't. You can dissagree with someone and probably will. For example, there is nothing wrong with disagreeing about a favorite color, however all disagreements will be handled in the most respectful way possible. People won't try to persuade others to think that their favorite color needs to be their favorite color also. And everybody agrees on the most important things in the real narnia such as aslan being king.
 
Back
Top