thoughts (not spoilers) on Hugo

Benisse

Perelandrian
Staff member
Royal Guard
A couple weeks ago someone introduced me to the book The Invention of Hugo Cabret by Brian Selznick, a fascinating children's novel that uses beautiful evocative illustrations to advance the story line -- and which actually won the Caldecott Medal (an honor usually reserved for the best children's picture book rather than illustrated novels). Although it is 530 pages, it reads really fast since so much is detailed double-page illustrations; and when I started reading it I could not put it down. It was delightful! So I assigned it for homeschool reading for my daughter last week...

When she first looked at the book she visibly balked, but sulkily sat down in the armchair in the living room to do her reading time. Thirty minutes later I peeked in on her and she was still engrossed... and she finished it three days later in time for the opening of Hugo, the luminous film based on the book. So we started our Thanksgiving Wednesday celebration by going to see it together with my husband.

It's not too often that I can say that I like a movie as much as the book, especially since I liked The Invention of Hugo Cabret so very much! But it's true. As could be expected, there are some changes to the original novel, but most of the changes I thought helped develop the characters more and underscored the themes so it made the movie more unified; and it is worth seeing more than once (at least for me). My daughter is already talking about buying the DVD (it's on her wanna-buy list along with Courageous).

In the story, and especially in the movie version, there is a powerful theme that runs throughout, that Love is the Key -- beautifully symbolized by an actual heart-shaped key. Love is what makes the difference between feeling used vs. feeling safe, between isolation and connectedness, between surviving and living. It makes the difference between drudgery vs. fulfillment and purpose in work.

Another related theme that is integral to the plot is Purpose--
and that is what spoke most strongly to my heart in regards to my daughter. At one point Hugo is trying to encourage another character who is wondering what her purpose in life is. He takes her up to a breath-taking view of the city of Paris and says,

"Sometimes I come up here at night,
even when I'm not fixing the clocks,
just to look at the city. I like to
imagine that the world is one big
machine. You know, machines never
have any extra parts. They have the
exact number and type of parts they
need. So I figure if the entire world
is a big machine, I have to be here for
some reason too." (p.378)

No extra parts!
To me that also means -->No extra chromosomes! There is a reason, a purpose for each of us they way we are. My daughter's having 47 not just 46 chromosomes is by design, not a mistake. And as a Christian I know the Person behind the plan, the One who is in control and who is at work fulfilling His carefully crafted purpose in her life...

What the world sometimes looks at and calls broken or purposeless, God calls *His*Beloved*.
 
I really had no interest in seeing it until I read the review by PluggedIn, and they gave it high marks, saying in conclusion: "I'll ask again, What happens when Martin Scorsese sets out to make something … completely different [from Scorsese's usual R-rated fare]? Hugo feels like a throwback to many of the beloved films of yesteryear. And at the same time, it serves as a powerful reminder that there are filmmakers in Hollywood who have the capacity to tell a spellbinding story without indulging in R-rated excess or crassly capitulating to commercialism." But since my money's rather tight right now, and I'm more interested in getting a gift for my parents as opposed to seeing a movie, I'll have to wait for Hugo at redbox or Netflix. But maybe I"ll pick up the book if I can find it. :)
 
WOW! Thanks so much for posting this, Benisse! And AK, thanks for the Plugged In review, I love those. I will definitely see this. But do I need to read the book first?
 
Great question...
You can enjoy the movie if you have not read the book.
BUT If there is any chance you will be reading the story
P-l-e-a-s-e read the book first!
Because the illustrations are so crucial to advancing the story, you will enjoy the book immensely more if you have no movie images in your mind when you read. And it is a rapid read -- my husband read it in about 2 hours.
 
Last edited:
I read the book a few years ago and I'm very eager to see the movie. I hope it lives up to the book. Like I said, I can't leave an accurate thought on it here because I have yet to see it, I'm just really excited for it.
 
Because of that book I found one of my favorite directors (Georges Melies), and I've read it at least a few times. It's really a good children's book. And the illustrations are quite pretty.
I might see the movie, just to see how it turned out. Ben Kinglsey is playing Melies. :)
 
BEST BOOK EVER.

For those who have not read it, you will not be disappointed. I read it last year and could hardly put it down. I was done with it in a little over three days. And it's a BIG book.
 
Back
Top