Which brother would you choose?

[im posting partly because i feel bad for this thread ;) ]

WILLIAM MOSELEY/PETER! Because he is the oldest one of the two and the hotter one ( i know thats argueable for some people but its my opinion). He's funny, outgoing, tall, and perfect. Yep... I could go on but I'm pretty tired ^_^;;
 
probably ill choose Peter as an older bro. but i like edmund, to tame! hehehe!:D i feel like i wanted to be called an older sister for a change,
 
hmm. That's a toughy you see because Edmund turns around so much and in Prince Caspian is the only one who sides with Lu when she sees aslan
But then again Peter is the oldest and it says in Caspian that he felt like Lu was his friend and fav sister and he wanted to comfort her.
HMMM!!! Oh wow this is hard!
I'm going to say Peter because he is the oldest and reminds me SO much of MY older brother whom I feel very close to.
But Ed is VERY sweet in Prince Caspian AND the Voyage of the dawn Tredor!
 
[COLOR=White]I would definitely choose Peter, I mean he has the best qualities, :D he's stronger, sure about himself, hotter, cute, inteligent, he's like a dream, I think Edmund just screws it up too much for my taste...I don't know, that's what I think... PETER IS THE BEST! :D [/COLOR]
 
Am I the only male so far in this topic - oh well! Are you talking about the film or the book? Either way I would say Peter or William as I found his character more amiable and I think I can identify with him more being almost the same age and big brother myself. With regards to William, to whom I think most of you are referring, in all honesty I do think that he is incredibly good-looking, a brilliant actor and I do like the way he speaks - it's nice to have a non-laboured, well-spoken English in today's generation!
 
I think it would be too biased to pick which one on a count of actors since one would probably go with the one they think is more attractive >.>

Between Edmund and Peter... that is tough =P Personally I'm more like Peter and we would probably get along... But Edmund seems likes the type (especially later in the series) that I would probably enjoy being around, he becomes so sweet xD So I'll go with Edmund.... Err maybe not XP I don't think he would be the most reliable in the world.. Edmund would probably be more funner to poke (they would be poked xD) Older Peter would probably snap if you poked him too many times ;_; That would make Arei sad... I do love Peter and Edmund >.< Too hard to choose!!
 
this is thought-provoking. I am an only child and always wondered what itwould be like to have other siblings. Large families still fascinate me. I would have to say it would be a tough chioce. William/Peter would be very stable, probably more quiet oftentimes, and helpful, I think. But Skandar/Edmund would be fun to hang out with, although probably much louder and somewhat annoying at times. I guess both would have good quatlties and not so good. The cool thing though, is if it were Skandar, every time he did something wrong I could yell "Skan-DAR!!!" like they did on the movie set whenever he did something wrong. That would be fun!
 
I like them both very much, but i like warrior;) and Peter is a warrior more than Ed.
Ive always liked Peter better, but i really like both Edmund and Peter.
 
I would have to saw Peter because he is my favorite charater (also Lucy) and he's so brave, so I would be inspired by him. But Edmund is very cool as well!
 
i luv will loads but as peter.... i dunno it kind of annoyed me when he kept going on at edmund for being so stupid. well actually, he was just being a good brother i guess. and he was honest to aslan. And i saw in an interview with the director that he thought the summary of the story was: peter going from a child to a young man, him learning blah blah and it was all about peter!! hehe, yeah my favourite character is peter.
 
I think I'd like Edmund to be my brother. I already have an annoying sister, but it'd be interesting to have an annoying brother too. Anyways, if i had Peter as a brother he'd be better at everything than me, so no thankyou lol. :p
 
William a.k.a. Peter is definately the best!! he is sooooo handsome. he is also the oldest and the leader. i love how he always watches out for lucy and his siblings. he isnt afraid to defend them and fight for them but only does it when neccessary!! i luv him!!
 
that's really a very hard decision. i'm an only child, and i think having an older brother sounds really fun. peter seems very understanding and accepting. however, in the movie, edmund was closer to my age and i feel like i could relate to him more.

anyway, they both seem very cool!
 
That's really hard... if I had to choose the Peter or Edmund in the LWW, I would probably choose Peter just because Edmund's mostly mean in that one until the end. However, in all the other books, I would choose Edmund because he's just so cool... maybe I would choose him anyway in the LWW.
 
neither I would go with Caspian or Reepicheep, acctually no I dont know which one, hmm I like peter because he seems like my oldest brother, protective but not overly so, but edmund is like my other brother, close to my age and kinda mean, but sorta protective too, ummm neither I will stick with my acctuall big brothers!!!
 
Back
Top