Will Edmund find out about Aslan's sacrifice

devoted

devoted

New member
In LWW Susan and Lucy decide not to tell Edmund about Aslan's sacrifice but he does know by the time of the Dawn Treader. Do you think they'll include a scene in Caspian showing Lucy or Susan telling Edmund.
 
I think he dose. He is king in narnia for a long time so he must find out. In fact, I think it says in The Houres and his boy that he dose. Ill have to check that one.
 
Narborg said:
I think he dose. He is king in narnia for a long time so he must find out. In fact, I think it says in The Houres and his boy that he dose. Ill have to check that one.
Click to expand...

sorry for double-pstong, but no

he nenevr dose find out. It does not say in HAHB
 
well remember in Horse and his boy how he said something about forgivig traitors for he knew of one particular trator that was forgiven???? that says that he might have found out, but it he could of also said that because he WAS forgiven, so i don't know. so what i just said doesn't really explain anything does it???may be the scene of when they said that will be in the directors cut, but even if they don't they shouldn't tell him in the movies.
 
it never says in the books that he finds out. We will never know what happened, because remember the "no one is told any story but there own" thing? that means that we won't find out what Aslan told Edmund during their talk, unless Edmund tells us, which won't be anytime soon.
 
devoted said:
In LWW Susan and Lucy decide not to tell Edmund about Aslan's sacrifice but he does know by the time of the Dawn Treader. Do you think they'll include a scene in Caspian showing Lucy or Susan telling Edmund.
Click to expand...
No because it wasn't in the book and that's a huge thing to just put in the movie for the heck of it. So - no.
 
In the movie, didn`t Edmund find out even though it wasn`t in the book. I mean Peter said to him "He`s gone" then Edmund said "Then you`ll have to lead us." Hmm.... What do you think Edmun thought happened to Aslan?
 
<Turkish Delight> said:
In the movie, didn`t Edmund find out even though it wasn`t in the book. I mean Peter said to him "He`s gone" then Edmund said "Then you`ll have to lead us." Hmm.... What do you think Edmun thought happened to Aslan?
Click to expand...


That's a good question. I'm in agreement that he never did find out about Aslan's sacrifice though...when Peter said, " Aslan is gone..." maybe Edmund thought Aslan was angry at him and abandoned them?
 
I also think it would have been part of what Aslan told Edmund in their talk.

I don't think that it will be included in any of the other bits in the EE, because it is a private talk between Aslan and Edmund, and it is up to each of us to decide what Aslan told Edmund.
 
Back
Top