Favorite Scene From The Lotr Movies

hmm, anything with pippin doing his jig or him in the shire and whatnot. Seriously, i just loved pippin. Though some of those fight scenes were just coolness.

tg
 
Actually trees and ents are not the same things. Ents are created by one of the Valar who feels sorry that the trees have no way to defend themselves so actually they are two different things because Ents are the shephards of the trees I mean Treebeard said himself he was not a tree.
 
The question remains...
...Do ents always remain ents? Treebeard remarks that ents can get "treeish" and go to sleep. It seems to be almost a parallel to humans who lose their humanity (stritly voluntarilly of course, I am not refering to those with brain injuries or retardation) and become akin to the beasts we are supposed to have dominion over...
...Confusing, but interesting...

-JS
 
It's really hard to choose just one favorite scene, cause I love a lot of them.
But if I have to name one is when Frodo arrives to Rivendell, and the whole fantastic valley that appears on the screen. Rivendell is my favorite Middle Earth place.
 
Last edited:
Iron Morgoth said:
But if I have to name one is when Frodo arrives to Rivendell, and the whole fantastic valley that appears on the screen. Rivendell is my favorite Middle Earth place.
Click to expand...

That scene was wonderful - Rivendell was breath-taking; it looked exactly as a pictured it in the book.

Rivendell is my favorite place as well Morgoth, so I was really glad to see it done so well in the movie. :)
 
My only problem with Rivendell is that there are no handrails on those narrow footpaths and bridges...LOL come on, tell me you didn't worry about Pippin falling off:)

-JS
 
Jene Sai said:
My only problem with Rivendell is that there are no handrails on those narrow footpaths and bridges...LOL come on, tell me you didn't worry about Pippin falling off:)

-JS
Click to expand...

Lol, well JS you know I was worried, but that's not suprising - what's interesting to me is that you were worried...I guess I must be having a negative influence on you or something...hehehehe.

-And you're right Legolas, Rivendell is where some of the elves lived. It's Elrond's home as well, as well as Bilbo's. :)
 
Hmmm... Favourite scene... Definately Faramir's charge where the knights get massacred... so many ideas displayed there... Arrogance, honour, sadness, futility, courage, love, selfishness... the list goes on. It was just so well done, and so sad... perfect.

And yeah, they should have put in the Scouring of the Shire. The entire point of the chapter in the book was to show the way the hobbits have grown and changed. At the beginning they're wide-eyed villagers, without a hope in the world of fighting evil on their own, but in that chapter we see them as they've become, without them being in the shadow of greater warriors like Aragorn and Gandalf. Even though it's just a skirmish in comparison to the war that's just finished, it proves them the heroes we know they are. It's the end to their character arcs (well, except for Frodo's... he's got a bit further to develop in the book before the end.)
 
Johan 72109 said:
Hmmm... Favourite scene... Definately Faramir's charge where the knights get massacred... so many ideas displayed there... Arrogance, honour, sadness, futility, courage, love, selfishness... the list goes on. It was just so well done, and so sad... perfect.
Click to expand...

I swear I'm the only person in the world who doesn't think of the many emotions that are incorporated in various scenes. I feel this is one of my greatest flaws...

Another scene I liked was when Pippin was singing, while the battle was going on in the third book. I thought that was very well done, and he has a very good singing voice (if that is him singing) I felt sad (yes! an emotion!) because the king didn't care what was going on.

(My knowledge of LOTR is the movies, and I can't remember every character's name. Sorry :o )
 
holyboy666 said:
Another scene I liked was when Pippin was singing, while the battle was going on in the third book. I thought that was very well done, and he has a very good singing voice (if that is him singing)
Click to expand...
Yes, it was! Isn't that amazing? You are right, that was a very dramatic scene.
 
It's three of them, but both are sad, at least to me.....TWO ARE IN RETURN OF THE KING, THE OTHER IN THE TWO TOWERS:

ONE: When the hobbits begin to bow down and Aragorn tells them not to and everyone else does. (RotK)

TWO: When Sam talks how they're going to be famous---he imitates the people wanting to hear about Frodo, but then Frodo imitates the people wanting to hear more about Sam. ((SAM'S DEVOTION IS THE PUREST (TTT))


THREE: At the end of RotK, it is when Frodo leaves, but gives a letter and the book to Sam. The voice over of Frodo talking to Sam made me cry, esp. when "And Back Again" plays. It is the end of the series, but the most endearing part of all three for me ((THIS IS MY ABSOLUTELY FAVORITE))
 
Welcome to NarniaFans I_am_puddleglum..
..this was one of the first forums I visited also..

Some of my favorite scenes..
TT...The scene at Helm's Deep about Gimli needing a box to stand on..and about "tossing a dwarf".

ROTK...When Arwen has the vision of her son while on her way to the grey havens (okay..I know it is corny and not in the book, but I can't help liking it anyway)

FOTR...When Pippin trys to get Aragorn to stop for "second breakfast" (Billy Boyd was perfectly cast!)

-JS
 
Last edited:
i_am_puddleglum said:
TWO: When Sam talks how they're going to be famous---he imitates the people wanting to hear about Frodo, but then Frodo imitates the people wanting to hear more about Sam. ((SAM'S DEVOTION IS THE PUREST (TTT)
Click to expand...

I LOVE that part. Sam is the best!

The second breakfast scene is hilarious, as is the dwarf tossing/dwarf-on-a-box scene.

I love when Eowyn says "I am no man!" and finally stabs the nasty tall dark *gggrrr* (passionate dislike for witch king)

OOO! When Sam fights shelob!

Ok, I better quit.
 
Back
Top