Harry Potter Book 7 *Contains Spoilers*

narnia+north said:
and not having harry go back to school would make the a book a disapointment.
Click to expand...
Well yes and no. I think Hogwarts did make the books a sucess. What a cool thing to imagine, a school of magic!
 
My friend actually had a good idea about RAB.

Regulas A. Black. :D

I think that's who RAB is. And I think Harry will find Snape and kill him and fight Draco but Draco goes to the light side. Then Sirius comes back (PLEASE!!!) and fights with Harry against Death Eaters. I also think Voldemort and Harry will die, and Harry's scar is a Horcrux so he has to destroy himself in order to destroy Voldemort. Ginny and Harry get back together sometime in the book (before he dies) and Ron and Hermione get married- of course. I mean, later on about 10 years, of course.

*sigh*

Those are my predictions.
 
As far as anyone knows though, R. Black is dead. So that would be a tough one to say he will go and kill him. He is the most likely candidate for that, but we don't know for sure, the wizarding world is larger than we know.

tg

PS He will end up at Hogwarts somehow, especially if Dumbledore is alive, but then again he could go underground if that is the case.
 
tgraveline said:
As far as anyone knows though, R. Black is dead. So that would be a tough one to say he will go and kill him. He is the most likely candidate for that, but we don't know for sure, the wizarding world is larger than we know.

tg

PS He will end up at Hogwarts somehow, especially if Dumbledore is alive, but then again he could go underground if that is the case.
Click to expand...

Ahhhh, but i do not think that Dumbldore is going to be alive! He needs to face Voldemort alone without his guardians.
 
Even if Dumbledore is alive, he won't be with Harry when he faces Voldemort in the ultimate showdown. Dumbledore is the one who told Harry that only one of them could live. So i think Dumbledore recognizes that he can't be there when Harry fights Voldemort. Oh, and Sirius won't come back. Remember, Nearly Headless Nick said that its only weak wizards who find ways to return. Sirius may have been egotistical but he was a strong wizard. He's dead and Harry won't see him again. And somehow I don't see Dumbledore coming back. It just doesn't make sense.
 
onlymystory said:
Even if Dumbledore is alive, he won't be with Harry when he faces Voldemort in the ultimate showdown. Dumbledore is the one who told Harry that only one of them could live. So i think Dumbledore recognizes that he can't be there when Harry fights Voldemort. Oh, and Sirius won't come back. Remember, Nearly Headless Nick said that its only weak wizards who find ways to return. Sirius may have been egotistical but he was a strong wizard. He's dead and Harry won't see him again. And somehow I don't see Dumbledore coming back. It just doesn't make sense.
Click to expand...

Very much agreed!!!
 
I'm not saying that Dumbledore is alive to help him kill Voldemort. I'm saying it is possible that he will be back in some form other than just the potrait in the headmaster's office.

tg
 
I'm not for sure to be honest. I do know there are many fantastical forms known though. There are a few he could take. I have these two books that are encylopedias of all things fantasy; big or small, fairy or spirt, it has everything. I have seen many things in there that she has taken exactly as they were, such as The Grim, Mandrakes(which I've been told is actually in the Bible as well in Songs of Solomon). The reason I say this is because what we know about the wizarding world is through Harry's eyes. Harry still doesn't know that much and is continually learning knew things each book he had no idea even existed.

tg
 
Lucy_QueenofNarnia said:
I also believe Dumbledore will come back in some form-- but he won't be there to help fight Voldemort with Harry. No... Harry's gotta do that himself.
Click to expand...

Totaly agree. But i don't think Dumbledore wil come back in any form... He is gone for good.
 
Probably because being there in spirit isn't the same as "being back, alive". Personally I find it more likely that Dumbledore would come back (and I also think he may not really be dead, just a setup plan) than be a spirit. Because the first thing you think when you think spirit is ghost, and only weak wizards who are too afraid to let go come back as ghosts (as we learn when Sirius died). And I don't think Dumbledore is the type of person who would be afraid of death, and leaving this world behind.
 
As far as the Death thing goes, JKR has been pretty consistent with dead people staying dead, so I don't think Dumbledore is coming back to life. She has said that D is definitely not a Jesus figure in one interview. And in another she has said that D is very much dead.
 
Back
Top