The first time Fish told me she wanted to turncoat was the round where i was killed. I waited with PMing her untill i was dead, and everyone knew i was a mafia. I then PMed her that we suspected either Gondorgirl and Ferny as the Psychic. We really suspected GG, but i didn't trust Fish at that time, and told her Ferny to, because i was afraid Ferny was the next to go. Strangely enough, from then, Ferny was off the hook with the voting, and GG was saved...
In the last round my original set-up was to tell Fish that we needed her help, because
Arien was the last mafia, and we wanted to make sure no one would vote for her. Of course that wasn't true. Me and the other mafia PMed a lot about this, and originally it was going to be like that (because at that moment i had no faith in Fish as being a real turncoat).
Then one thing happened that changed it all, when i got a reply from Fish, telling that she really was a turncoat, day had already started and both Arien and Olorin already voted for LA, there was simply no point in telling Fish that Arien was our last mafia anymore, it was just too late
. So i did the only thing that might have helped, and told her the truth. LA was going to die anyway, and this was my last shot. In the end it wouldn't have mattered if i asked Fish anything or not
(btw Fish, the first time you told me you were going to turncoat i didn't trust you
at all, only the second time, when we were first going to tell you a lie, i started doubting. Very good!)
But it was a very very fun game! The number one moment is where i got to know all good jobs, the number two moment is the extremely angry PM i got from Olorin when he found out i lied all the time
(Oh, and btw, we did not know GG's job for sure, but guessed from her suspicious behaviour...)
(btw 2, Olorin, did you really save yourself every night?)