Mafia Game Nine

Sir Benjamin the Lion said:
lol. Clever of them, but I have their names. But Fish, you're one of the Mafia.
Click to expand...

She's not one of the Mafia, she's just a turncoat civilian. :p

fish_wwjd_frog said:
haha, I happen to know she's not the angel. And yes, it does make sense.
Click to expand...

Would you care to explain HOW you know?

*IOWW the Iasc* said:
And yes, I said gang, because that's what they are. If you haven't noticed, it's the same people that do everything against everybody. They're one unit, whereas I have voted wiht my own opinion, and even helped vote out a murderer myself!
Click to expand...

You only switched your vote to Slp after it was clear that she was goin' down...
 
Olórin the Wise said:
You only switched your vote to Slp after it was clear that she was goin' down...
Click to expand...

Okay...last post until later...

Actually, I very well could ahve gone back to vote DoG and tied it up. It wasn't clear that she would die at all, with the exception of your little troupe's votes and scheming. I could have rallied for DoG and campaigned for her if I wanted. I guess it was good that you all convinced me to vote for her. You all were right then, but you're not right now.
 
*IOWW the Iasc* said:
Actually, I very well could ahve gone back to vote DoG and tied it up. It wasn't clear that she would die at all, with the exception of your little troupe's votes and scheming. I could have rallied for DoG and campaigned for her if I wanted. I guess it was good that you all convinced me to vote for her. You all were right then, but you're not right now.
Click to expand...

Actually, if you had tied it up, they BOTH would have died. In which case you would have fallen under IMMEDIATE suspicion of Mafianess. So, you decided that since Slp was gonna die at any rate, and you would be suspected if you didn't vote for her, you voted for her.

fish_wwjd_frog said:
Why would I share my sources when you won't share yours?
Click to expand...

Because mine would kill me if I told. Would yours? Did you see a printscreen of a non-Angel PM from her?

Oh and by the way, everybody... we can't really trust Mafia if they show printscreens of civilian PM's anymore, unless you can see the thingy up in the top-right corner that says, "Welcome, so-and-so". You see, Fish could very well have lent them hers, so they could throw off suspicion.
 
Olórin the Wise said:
Actually, if you had tied it up, they BOTH would have died. In which case you would have fallen under IMMEDIATE suspicion of Mafianess. So, you decided that since Slp was gonna die at any rate, and you would be suspected if you didn't vote for her, you voted for her.



Because mine would kill me if I told. Would yours? Did you see a printscreen of a non-Angel PM from her?
Click to expand...

I'm doing a really bad job of not posting here...

Actually, I never thought of leaving it tied, although that would've been the ideal solution. We could've gotten two murderers with one stone.

How can your source kill you? You're already dead.
 
Olórin the Wise said:
Because mine would kill me if I told. Would yours? Did you see a printscreen of a non-Angel PM from her?

Oh and by the way, everybody... we can't really trust Mafia if they show printscreens of civilian PM's anymore, unless you can see the thingy up in the top-right corner that says, "Welcome, so-and-so". You see, Fish could very well have lent them hers, so they could throw off suspicion.
Click to expand...

Yours would kill you if you told? Does that mean your source is mafia?

And how do you know they could borrow my PM, Olorin? What makes you so sure that I'm just a civvie?
 
Are you trying to say that you have a job? OK, then send me a PM with a printscreen of your job PM in it, big enough to show your name in the top right-hand corner.

Never say I didn't give you a fair chance.
 
Olórin the Wise said:
Are you trying to say that you have a job? OK, then send me a PM with a printscreen of your job PM in it, big enough to show your name in the top right-hand corner.

Never say I didn't give you a fair chance.
Click to expand...

You've obviously betrayed others. You give me no reason to trust you. And anyway, I don't quite see the good it would do. You seem convinced that I'm turncoat anyway.
 
Ahh, so you ARE a civilian after all? I see...

If you don't want me to think you a turncoat, vote for IOWW. :p

And what makes you think I've betrayed the others? I was the one who STARTED them after Slp!!
 
Olórin the Wise said:
Ahh, so you ARE a civilian after all? I see...

If you don't want me to think you a turncoat, vote for IOWW. :p

And what makes you think I've betrayed the others? I was the one who STARTED them after Slp!!
Click to expand...

Think what'd you'd like about what my job is and where my loyalties lie, but I'm not voting the way you want me to vote to prove my innocence.

Oh, and I didn't mean that you had betrayed the civilians.
 
So, Fishy, who are you saying I DID betray, huh? In case you didn't notice, your Mafia pals killed ES, and thereby me, and I have been proven to be a Civilian, so you can't say I'm Mafia... :rolleyes:
 
Olórin the Wise said:
So, Fishy, who are you saying I DID betray, huh? In case you didn't notice, your Mafia pals killed ES, and thereby me, and I have been proven to be a Civilian, so you can't say I'm Mafia... :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Hmm...well, due to recent developments, I've decided to revoke my accusations of you being a turncoat. Or, at least, of you being an aware of being a turncoat. This has not come about from your posts, of course. But I do think you are in for a surprise at the end of this game...
 
I know Lauren knows a turncoat, and they are a turncoat Mafia. You were so sure of the Mafia, that you must be teaming up with other turncoats to get us, not by your own knowledge, but by being sneaky. *shakes head* Next Mafia game we need to re-make the rules.
 
Back
Top