Copperfox
Well-known member
To avoid a hairpulling fight between sisters, I'll give LocoRoco a comment also:
>> Anna stepped down from the plinth and went and stood next to Auraya.
>> "Do you, Auraya wish to accept these robes and this guardian, or do you
>> wish to go home stripped of your powers?"
>> "I do." Auraya said defiantly, and looked up with a ferocious look in her eyes.
If I asked you, "Do you prefer orange juice or tea?" and you said "Yes," you would not be answering my question. Auraya, in the excerpt shown, was not answering the question, because the way Anna worded the question, Auraya's answer could equally mean either choice. I know, I know, the readers are supposed to assume that Auraya wants to press forward; but there can be other cases where there is less for the readers to go on, so you need to keep in mind how to make things clear for them.
>> Anna stepped down from the plinth and went and stood next to Auraya.
>> "Do you, Auraya wish to accept these robes and this guardian, or do you
>> wish to go home stripped of your powers?"
>> "I do." Auraya said defiantly, and looked up with a ferocious look in her eyes.
If I asked you, "Do you prefer orange juice or tea?" and you said "Yes," you would not be answering my question. Auraya, in the excerpt shown, was not answering the question, because the way Anna worded the question, Auraya's answer could equally mean either choice. I know, I know, the readers are supposed to assume that Auraya wants to press forward; but there can be other cases where there is less for the readers to go on, so you need to keep in mind how to make things clear for them.