The Horse And His Boy: Not So Necessary?

Should they film Horse and His Boy?

  • Yes! That's the one I'm most waiting for!

    Votes: 42 29.4%

  • Yes, it's as worthy as any others to be made.

    Votes: 78 54.5%

  • Yes, but just to make the series complete.

    Votes: 14 9.8%

  • Make it or not, I don't care.

    Votes: 5 3.5%

  • No, focus all efforts on the other stories.

    Votes: 2 1.4%

  • No, it doesn't fit with the other stories.

    Votes: 2 1.4%

  • No! I hated that story!

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • The Horse and his what?

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    143
make me executive producer ^.^

Yeah, if CS Lewis wrote it, they better make it.

I voted for its worthy just as much as the others to be made
 
Last edited:
This book should absolutely be made into a movie. While most of the book is focused on an adventure outside of Narnia, it does encompass the Pevensies when they are older and actually ruling Narnia. Also, C.S. Lewis wrote HHB for a reason and therefore it is an important part of the series.

Plus it would make an excellant movie.
 
They should DEFINITELY make 'Horse & Boy'! It's great, and I love it when they show the 4 Pevensie kids grown up- although Peter and Lucy aren't in it that much :(

But it's definitely worth watching and making! I can't WAIT for this one!

:D
 
Horse and his boy

I think it's a ridiculous idea to not do the magicians nephew first, for me that was the third most enjoyable book and the second most important. I also think the horse and his boy was one of the best and should not be left out,none should be left out they are all brilliant books. If they left out any boooks i'd be quite angry :mad
 
I really, really, really, REALLY want them to make The Horse and His Boy!!
I LOVE that book. It's one of my favorites! I love it so much!
Aravis is one of my favorite characters!! I think it's so cool. It really shows us about the other areas of the world that Narnia is in. It shows so much about Calormene culture, it's so cool. I love it!
 
I don't think the HHB should be left out at all. First of all it gives us a glimpse as to what happens during the Pevensies' reign as kings and queens of Narnia, introduces new and interesting characters, and also gives us a look at the Calormene culture, remarkably similiar to the Turks or other Middle Eastern cultures. Plus who could resist the 'love hate' relationship between Cor/Shasta and Aravis? She was feisty and beautiful.
 
pacifiquesea said:
If anything, they might tack the story onto one of the other movies. It's a good book, but I think that's the practical decision.
Click to expand...
Yes, but if it is, it should be onto LWW, since it's in the Golden Age in Narnia. But I would love it if they made it its own movie, and SOON!!!
 
i think they should make THAHB, i read it, and think it's a great part of the series. they need to make it!
 
I voted that it is "as worthy as any other movie to be made" because it's a great story about destiny. I think that all the CoN books have a moral, and this book has a lot to do with destiny. It's a lot like a Narnian Cinderella story, except with a boy named Shasta! :p
 
I agree that it could give another look at Susan and help people understand why she ends up the way she does in LB. It's a chance to really flush out her character. HHB is another chance to help develop Aslan. It shows his goodness and yet his untame side which should be highlighted before LB as well. When all is said and done in LB, it would look pretty strange for the characters of Aravis and Shasta as well as all of the others to be there if HHB is left out. Personally, since it's a 7 book set it should be a 7 movie set as well. It wouldn't be right without it. The set of movies would always be a little lacking if any one book were cast aside.
 
Into the Wardrobe said:
I agree that it could give another look at Susan and help people understand why she ends up the way she does in LB. It's a chance to really flush out her character. HHB is another chance to help develop Aslan. It shows his goodness and yet his untame side which should be highlighted before LB as well. When all is said and done in LB, it would look pretty strange for the characters of Aravis and Shasta as well as all of the others to be there if HHB is left out. Personally, since it's a 7 book set it should be a 7 movie set as well. It wouldn't be right without it. The set of movies would always be a little lacking if any one book were cast aside.
Click to expand...

I so agree there....I've looked at the books as each one being equally important.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top