BBC, Animated or Disney?

[Sisteuber]

I cannot stand animated stuff....so I vote for Disney cause I've never seen BBC...

 

[Aslan's Beloved Daughter]

I saw BBC and Aslan, I am afraid to say, scared me. He was just a stuffed animal! And I know that they didn't have CG back then....but COME ON!!! And Aslan's voice haunted me! Whoever was used for his voice cannot compare to Liam Neeson. Liam beats him so badly...
anyways, I choose Disney. They were a lot better at making the movie than BBC was.

 

[SlpNarniaQueen]

Disney! Disney disney!

 

[Tsurugi]

Of course,Disney is great！

 

[King Of Narbithia]

Well, of course Disney is better, but the bbc is just more narniash like the music at the beggining and like the whole narnia but disney is better, but bbc is also great,

Long Live Aslan!

 

[anna fan for life]

I LOVE THE DISNEY ONE I hate the animated ine the BBC is ok

 

[I♥Georgie]

I LOVE THE DISNEY ONE I hate the animated ine the BBC is ok

yeah me too

 

[DjStickymuffinz]

Disney!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Queen Aravis]

I went for disney, even tho both the BBC one and the animated one are brilliant

 

[King Of Narbithia]

well i never seen the animated Narnia.. i want to really bad though.. does anyone know if the witch was screamy like barbara, middle , or like tilda ...

 

[Son of Adam]

Although the BBC production and the animated film (both of which I have) were truer to the actual story line of LWW, the Disney adaptation of the book, because of the scenery, the special effects, etc., made Narnia much more real than the other two which is why I voted for the Disney version of LWW.