Unknown for Jill and Polly???

Do you think unknown actresses should play Polly Plummer and Jill Pole?

  • Total voters
    109
go OFFICE! well unkknown for jill and polly? well it doesn't have to be completly unknown like anna popplewell was nkown, and like the bridge to terabithia cast, thatd be cool, some one thats been there but we never actually noticed them... but if u mean known as in ppl like amanda bynes or those kind of "all american" girls... then BITE ME.
 
I deffinetly think that unkown actresses should play as Jill and Polly. I don't want something like "ALISON STONER AS JILL POLE!" I just want "Jill Pole".
If someone already famous played Polly or Jill, you'd think of Jill/Polly as the famous actress other than seeing the actress and thinking of her as Jill/Polly. It's also much more fun being introduced to new actresses other than already seeing them in like 5 million other movies. It's really hard to explain it, but that's how I feel.
 
I agree.Someone unknown would be better for the part of Jill than say Emmma Watson.Because you are going to think of her as Hermonie Granger or Emmma Watson
 
i agree it kind makes everyhing new and more interesting cause if someone played in a movie before you would assoicaite him or her with a part that was played and it would kind of cause you to by typecast as a hero or a bad guy or a farm boy or whatever it would kinda take away the illusion
 
skyla sue said:
i agree it kind makes everyhing new and more interesting cause if someone played in a movie before you would assoicaite him or her with a part that was played and it would kind of cause you to by typecast as a hero or a bad guy or a farm boy or whatever it would kinda take away the illusion
Click to expand...

Also, they'd look too "act-y". lol.
 
iut depends really. i would pick an unkown over a known if she was better! it would make things more interesting. the pevensies were unkown. well to me anyway!
 
Hmm... hard to say. If the unknown is good they should definitly pick her. um.. I'm unknown... :)
 
If you don't give unknowns (like myself...Well I'm known...slightly, in my home state) a chance, you'll never get anymore actors! UNKNOWNS!!!!!!
 
I think that the main thing most of us love are the stories of Narnia that CS Lewis wrote and we don't want to see them spoiled. With known actors and actresses it would become more about who is staring in the movie as opposed to the story being at center stage. I like the idea of unknown actors. If they've been in other movies in non-staring roles that's fine because then they have some experience, but I really love the idea of unknown people so that the story isn't diminished.
 
Into the Wardrobe said:
I think that the main thing most of us love are the stories of Narnia that CS Lewis wrote and we don't want to see them spoiled. With known actors and actresses it would become more about who is staring in the movie as opposed to the story being at center stage. I like the idea of unknown actors. If they've been in other movies in non-staring roles that's fine because then they have some experience, but I really love the idea of unknown people so that the story isn't diminished.
Click to expand...

I totally agree. I hate watching a movie and thinking the whole time about the other character that actor has played. And it bugs me when a company is selling a movie by the actors not the great story. I don't think the Chronicles of Narnia movies need big names to be hits. They're awesome stories on their own.
 
Oh, Christ!!! That girl, the one who played Jill is gorgeus!!! I feel terribly, I don't know If I'm gonna get there... OOOHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anyway, my hair is brown, just like hers now, i coloured my hair a few days ago, haha. so, i hope I can play Jill soon... nopw, I'm doing my bussiness for thast.. actually, I played her in a play we had in theater in my town of the Silver chair. it was so lokmng, I'll bring you pics... Eustace was really fun, ha.
 
I think unknown actresses should play Jill and Polly, but there are also "known" actresses that possibly could... I would love to play either but I might be too old. Or at least for the younger Polly I'm already to old!
 
you know what ...i rather not have a TOTALLY unknown person. someone who has their filmography like anna popplewell, or better yet, freddie highmorehe's always in like the best movies! all of them!!!but yet he still has that unknown character...i dunno...gotta stop saying that!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top