Who'd win in a fight, Edmund or Eustace?

Edmund, he's had the experiance of fighting in the Battle, and he's a king, and he's a Pevensie... :)

He had practise aswell, and because he's cool :D
 
Edmund vs. Eustace

Interesting question. pre-Narnia, Edmond would beat Eustace effortlessly, and he would run off looking for some Plumtree Vitimanized Nerve Food.

Post LWW/VoDT? Edmund would still win, but it would be closer. Now, if Edmund had encountered Eustace as a dragon, the only way to tell is DNA evidence in Eustace dragon's droppings (and even that would be tough).

Post SC (no one has talked about that!), it would probably be a pretty even fight. Although Eustace still had some significant shortcomings in SC, he had matured a great deal and was much more the warrior.
 
Edmund definitely

I am a new member of the forum. I pretty sure that Even when he was rude, Edmund would have won because in the Dawn Treader Lewis makes a point to say that even Lucy could win against Eustace.
 
When Eustace was first introduced, it was stated that he was not capable of beating even Lucy in a fight, much less Edmund. Although his Narnian experiences doubtless made him as much physically tougher as morally better, I doubt he would have caught up with Edmund in the short career he had.
 
What well!

umm, i think edmond, just because he was like king for twenty years, and had been in sooo many more wars and battles than eustace, but still eustace could do some damage, that is, after the voyage of the dawn treader
 
um....well i dont know who the other dude is soooooo.....i'll say.....EDMUND!! :D
but i did hear that the other dude can change into a dragon which i have to say that is really cool!! :D
 
the black elf said:
um....well i dont know who the other dude is soooooo.....i'll say.....EDMUND!! :D
but i did hear that the other dude can change into a dragon which i have to say that is really cool!! :D
Click to expand...

yes, he did turn into a dragon in the dawn treader.
 
Back
Top