Alambil and Tarvis
New member
No don't worry. I seriously don't think it's that big a deal. I believe they are both just taken by her beauty. I don't think it's going to turn into an all out battle or even as major a thing as Suspian was. I think possibly they stuck that bit in the movie for laughs and also to let veiwers know that Ramandu's daughter is very beautiful. In the book it says something like they had never known what beauty was until they saw her or something to that effect. So it would make sense, in the film adaption, to have more than one person find her beautiful. After all opinions on beauty to vary. Where some think Laura Brent is very beautiful, others find her plain. You're never gonna find one woman who everyone agrees is just IT so you have to make it plain to the audience that in the movie she is IT.
Yeah, I completely agree with that. Again, it does say in the book that basically she is supposed to be very beautiful, and pretty much every guy from the Dawn Treader is like "OMG who is THAT" in the book (that's the impression I got, anyway ). So it's not like it's a big deal. If a very beautiful woman (who happened to be a star 5 seconds ago and is still glowing, btw ) just randomly appeared in front of a bunch of men who've been stuck on a ship for weeks/months, obviously they're ALL going to be considerably distracted
Besides, Caspian was a naive young man! in PC ^_^ And it's been 3 YEARS since then...I mean, I've had plenty of crushes within the last 3 years. We go through those like wildfire sometimes xD It's not like he was madly in love with Susan; it was more like...oh, you're a girl and I like you. Yay. The end. That kind of thing.