The Arwenites and Eowynites.
- Thread starter Sir Godfrey
- Start date
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
Well in the meantime, thanks GG for helping revive mine. 
You're welcome I'm good at revivals
I'm good at revivals
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
You're welcome
Hahaha! So am I. Together nothing can stop us! Muhahahaha! XD
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
oooh we should revive something else
I've revived a few topics, but if I want to really go gung ho.. I should revive something from three years ago. XD
Mrs Gil-Galad Took
New member
Revival of the fittest No that's survival of the fittests
No that's survival of the fittests 
SingingDryad~
New member
Thank goodness for the Revivenites.
I'm an Eowynite all the way. She's amazing, and you can easily relate to her stubborness, fear and anger. And she was just as good in the movies as in the books, whereas Arwen's character was, in my opinion, somewhat modified for the worst in the movies. Sorry, Peter Jackson.
As a bonus, I love Rohan.
I'm an Eowynite all the way. She's amazing, and you can easily relate to her stubborness, fear and anger. And she was just as good in the movies as in the books, whereas Arwen's character was, in my opinion, somewhat modified for the worst in the movies. Sorry, Peter Jackson.
As a bonus, I love Rohan.
Last edited:
Mrs Gil-Galad Took
New member
Now we keep this thread up So me and SD are now the revivers
So me and SD are now the revivers
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
My passion for Arwen may have faded, but my love for her character shall never be purged!
Eowyn is always awesome
did you know that Tolkien originally was going to have Aragorn marry Eowyn?
did you know that Tolkien originally was going to have Aragorn marry Eowyn?
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
Eowyn is always awesome
did you know that Tolkien originally was going to have Aragorn marry Eowyn?
Affiramtive, that is one of the reasons I don't get to upset over the short romance between Aragorn and Eowyn in The Two Towers film. In a way it shows us what could have been, what Tolkien had intended originally.
Affiramtive, that is one of the reasons I don't get to upset over the short romance between Aragorn and Eowyn in The Two Towers film. In a way it shows us what could have been, what Tolkien had intended originally.
actually I've always just considered that a movie-fied version of what happened in the book
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
actually I've always just considered that a movie-fied version of what happened in the book
The only difference being that Aragorn did seem to recipicate feelings toward Eowyn (especially in the TTT Extended Edition and the beginning of the ROTK). In book he just gave her the shaft. XD
no, I never noticed him reciprocating feelings toward her, he was just too nice to tell her otherwise
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
no, I never noticed him reciprocating feelings toward her, he was just too nice to tell her otherwise
Well he gave her signals and if he wasn't a bit interested then he would have stayed more distant and assumed his more reclusive/quiet nature.
Frankly I think there was intention to make Aragorn appear as if he had feelings, maybe not deep romantic ones like he shared with Arwen. But a bond that could have formed into something more. It does help that in movie they added in the drama of him breaking it off with Arwen the night before he leaves with the Fellowship. I personally don't care for added drama, especially when in regards to epics like LOTR.
Last edited:
In the books Eowyn was best. I would have liked the Arwen of the movies if she had been played by Brooke Shields!!!
Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
Eowyn was more productive in movies for sure, but Arwen will always be more beautiful.
Well he gave her signals and if he wasn't a bit interested then he would have stayed more distant and assumed his more reclusive/quiet nature.
Frankly I think there was intention to make Aragorn appear as if he had feelings, maybe not deep romantic ones like he shared with Arwen. But a bond that could have formed into something more. It does help that in movie they added in the drama of him breaking it off with Arwen the night before he leaves with the Fellowship. I personally don't care for added drama, especially when in regards to epics like LOTR.
I never thought there was, even with the added drama, he was just missing Arwen and kept thinking about her while Eowyn was talking to him