Apolo's Trial

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

That is a valid question: Why did Elindil want to duel so much?

 

[Saruman]

Would you pleese shut yer gob! I`m in a trial here

If you speak to me like that again, Pirate, the guards of Cair Paravel shall remove your presence from this Court. You have no place to speak. You are here only to respond to questions.

 

[Jill Pole Queen of Narnia]

Ifought to save me skin. Yes, the preasure was intence.

If you did not want to continue the duel, you could have left.

 

[the town hippie]

Did she in any way preassured you verbally? If so what was she saying?

Um, can ye brake dat down fer me, pleese?

 

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

Why does it matter if he's a Pirate, a Ranger, or a Seahorse? This court is supposed to be impartial.

 

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

If you did not want to continue the duel, you could have left.

Objection: This would be taken as cowardice, and would almost certainly have been raised as a scandal.

 

[the town hippie]

If you did not want to continue the duel, you could have left.

I could have, but i didn`t.

 

[Saruman]

Lady Jill, please pose questions. Your role is not to share opinions at present.

 

[QA48]

Um, can ye brake dat down fer me, pleese?

When ye told the ranger that ye were tired, did she say something like "Oh ye are nothing but a coward, if ye are man enough ye would not have a problem dueling with me!" Something along those lines...

 

[Knight Aaron of Narnia]

Before you declare this, you must first provide ample evidence that the rules of dueling and fencing are, in fact, the same.

ooc ~ I found a site it sai the following:The object of fencing is to hit the other person without being hit. It is a sport based on dueling practices, unique because like many martial arts the object is to hit the other person, simulating a debilitating injury. Fencing is susceptible to common sports injuries, but because fencing is predicated on causing injury, there is a greater chance that catastrophic injuries can occur.

ic ~ in this book it says:The object of fencing is to hit the other person without being hit. It is a sport based on dueling practices.

 

[the town hippie]

When ye told the ranger that ye were tired, did she say something like "Oh ye are nothing but a coward, if ye are man enough ye would not have a problem dueling with me!" Something along those lines...

If i recall corectly, she said I wanted to leave because i was chicken, or somthing like that.

 

[Knight Aaron of Narnia]

The art of fencing is based on dueling.
The rules are very close.
And a simple question,
Why did you stab Elindil?

 

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

Actually, I find no evidence of verbal coeircieon at the start of the duel, here:
http://www.narniafans.com/forum/showthread.php?t=5537&page=240&pp=10

 

[QA48]

If i recall corectly, she said I wanted to leave because i was chicken, or somthing like that.

I see, so she practically made you fight her. If that is so, She should have expected for the worst! Even DEATH!

 

[Gondor Knight of Narnia]

OOC-psssst!The only thing is, in a duel, the participants are generally trying to maim/injure/impose bodily harm or even kill each other. I would think of fencing-if it were to be w/ real swords n' harmin' each other-as a form of dueling

IC-Sparky stayed silent, unmoving...waiting...

 

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

If i recall corectly, she said I wanted to leave because i was chicken, or somthing like that.

Would you like to rephrase that? Or use the claim that your memory is bad because you were tired?

 

[Knight Aaron of Narnia]

I have a simple question,
Why did you stab Elindil?

 

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

I see, so she practically made you fight her. If that is so, She should have expected for the worst! Even DEATH!

Pardon me, but it was already clarified that no verbal coercion was used.

 

[the town hippie]

Would you like to rephrase that? Or use the claim that your memory is bad because you were tired?

Perhaps. I was ratheer tierd.

 

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

I can tell, by your sloppy moves at the beginning.