I dont know.....the movie....well they always mess it up....I say that it is aweful until it is proven to be otherwise......hmmmm I am soooo mad at some boys!!!.........we were discussing Eragon, in a book group, and we were only supposed to talk about Eragon, and say nothing about Eldest, since alot of us hadnt read it yet, me being one of them, and I said (dont answer the question) "I think Galbatorix is Eragon's father" and they were like its.....blah blah blah and then I said "I will be so mad if Roran betrays Eragon" and they were like its....bla h blah blah...I got so mad they kept answering, I was like guys I was just throwing that out there, I didnt want you to answer this, and I told them before I said it "dont answer this!! But I......" and they just dont listen so I want to beat them, and I know that when you have read the 2nd book in a series or something its hard to keep that a secret but honestly you have to!!!! Its just cruel to do otherwise and wroong cuz then people expect it and thats just wrong.....its like telling somebody exactly how they die.....but not telling them when....