Sir Godfrey
Pelegrin Crucis
I don't think in the series LOTF Luke is actually abusive. I just think the author writes the scene in a very bad way, making it sound worse than it is. I think what troubles me is that if a kid who was actually being abused read that moment, they might come away thinking what happened to them was okay, because Luke is a hero and he does it too. it just is that when I read that scene, I think of about fifty less awkward ways in which it can be written, but that story was by Denning, who seems to exist to create awkward EU moments. I wonder where the editor was on that one. They really dropped the ball...
I don't think an abusive Luke will make it to the big screens. No audience would want to see that, and I think Disney still wants to be seen as family friendly, even though Star Wars always specialized in the dysfunctional family.
I can understand that. It's a shame that today there is a trend of fallen heroes. No longer can a character be like the steadfast Aragorn or the pious King Arthur. Now it is the anti-hero that pollutes stories and makes the old conflict of good and evil impossible.
Frankly, I haven't found a good EU writer. There arn't any SW books I can even recommend to friends because they are often soap-operaesque. However, I haven't read LOTF or LOTJ, so maybe I am missing out.