Our fan review section is back after a years-long hiatus. We’ve added a new “focus” mode to it, and you can type numbers as you go through and rate things from 1-5.

← All reviews of The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005)

Review by Impressive Casting

4.8 / 5

Forget Bambi, Snow White, and The Incredibles. This is a Disney film that entertains, enchants and even moves you emotionally. Andrew Adamson, live-action debutant, has stayed as faithful to the book as Chris Columbus stayed to the two first Potter-books, without the soulless result. This is in fact one of the few times a film has managed to capture the spirit of a book as well as its plot and characters.

The effects and make-up on this film are well thought through, even for our digitally advanced standards, set by LOTR and The Matrix. Adamson shows promise as a live-action director; "Narnia" never feels choppy. But apart from all the visual delightments, it is the acting that is the most impressive.

William Moseley, who plays Peter, the eldest, delivers a strong and independent character. In many ways, he is the Cedric Diggory that the film version of Harry Potter 4 failed to transfer from the book to screen. Especially his relationship to Edmund (Skandar Keynes) is wonderfully portrayed. Probably not finding that much of a challenge in the typical hero-figure, Moseley creates his own in Peter's weaknesses.

Susan (Anna Popplewell) is the one of the foursome who has the least to do in the film. She is shown as a girl more interested in reason than imagination, a would-be mother figure for her siblings. Her cool, reasoning attitude serves as a premonition for her renouncement of Narnia in the last book of the series. Popplewell, being more experienced with movie-making than the others, handles Susan's emotions and characteristics with ease.

Skandar Keynes enters the scene as the less than sympathetic Edmund. In the first few scenes, we witness him risking his life for a photo of his father, refuse a hug from his mother, and mock his sister. The dynamic between Edmund and Peter is set early, and continues throughout the film. More to the script's (and C. S. Lewis') credit than Keynes', his motivations for betraying his brother and sister are clearly explained. Keynes' portrayal is, however, definitively on the same level as Rupert Grint's Ron in the Potter films, or Freddie Highmore's Charlie in "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory".

And now we come to the pride and joy of this film, Georgie Henley. Her interpretation of the sweet little Lucy is wonderful and heartbreaking. There's nothing more to say on that matter.

Other noteworthy performances must also be taken into account. The voice of Aslan (Liam Neeson, who, incidentally looks like a lion in real life) is mild, forceful, noble and sad. Tilda Swinton is scary and malevolent, not the "funny", stupid Disney-villain at all. Kiran Shah, James McAvoy and Jim Broadbent shine in their smaller threads of the tapestry.

"The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe" is a film with two wonderful atmospheres. First, "The Hobbit"-like, cute and cosy anglophilia. Second, an epic, medieval story in Arthurian fashion. Forget the Christian underlying morale and enjoy the year's best fantasy film.
(One minus, though: "The Fox" is ridiculous and unnecessary, but it's a kid's film, so...)

Share: X Facebook Reddit Email

Category scores

Directing5
Acting5
Screenplay5
Cinematography5
Music (Score)4
Art Direction4
Costume Design5
Make-Up5
Special Effects5
Editing5

Cast

Liam Neesonas Aslan4
William Moseleyas Peter Pevensie4
Anna Popplewellas Susan Pevensie4
Georgie Henleyas Lucy Pevensie5
Skandar Keynesas Edmund Pevensie5
James McAvoyas Mr. Tumnus5
Ray Winstoneas Mr. Beaver3
Dawn Frenchas Mrs. Beaver3
Rupert Everettas Fox3
James Cosmoas Father Christmas2
Tilda Swintonas The White Witch5
Kiran Shahas Ginarrbrik4
Michael Madsenas Maugrim3
Patrick Kakeas Oreius3
Shane Rangias Otmin3
Jim Broadbentas Professor Kirke5
Elizabeth Hawthorneas Mrs. Macready5
Judy McIntoshas Mrs. Pevensie5

Moments & details

Andrew Adamson in bringing The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to the big screen5
The realism of the computer-generated creatures and armies of Narnia5
The opening bombing-raid scenes in London4
The realization of Lucy meeting Mr. Tumnus on screen5
The addition of the escape on the icy river by Peter, Susan and Lucy4
The realization of meeting Aslan for the first time on screen5
The realization of The Stone Table on screen5
The Battle at the Fords of Beruna5
The resurrection of Aslan5
The final sequence at Cair Paravel4
The Hunt for the White Stag2
The emotional effect of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe5
Rating scale:1 Poor2 Fair3 Good4 Great5 Amazing

Submit your own review