Our fan review section is back after a years-long hiatus. We’ve added a new “focus” mode to it, and you can type numbers as you go through and rate things from 1-5.

← All reviews of The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005)

Review by Oddish

4.3 / 5

The movie was a very proficiently done retelling of C.S. Lewis's beloved children's book. Director Andrew Adamson was plainly busier than a one-legged man in a fanny-kicking contest, dealing ably with the incredible logistics involved with employing no fewer than three CGI companies at once, shooting on-location on several continents, ensuring that the book is faithfully adapted into a movie, and getting fine performances out of his four young leads. However, he clearly rose to the challenge.

All of the actors and actresses are quite convincing. Tilda Swinton's White Witch is properly scary without becoming a silly cliche. William Moseley as Peter captures his character's difficult and sometimes uncertain journey from young British boy to warrior-king. Anna Popplewell does her best with Susan, who I saw as a somewhat forgettable character, at least in this book. Skandar Keynes is spot-on as Edmund, though his character is most interesting early on, when he is at odds with the others. And the standout among the children is the terminally adorable Georgie Henley, who does an outstanding job bringing Lucy to life, making her likable without being cloying. If Aslan is capable of having favorites, Lucy is definitely one of his, and Henley makes it easy to see why. The chemistry between the children shows as well, as well as between Henley and James McAvoy, who plays Tumnus the fawn, deftly capturing the character's deep inner conflict. And Liam Neeson gives us an Aslan who is stately but kind and benevolent.

I'm no expert on 1940's England, but the costumes seemed right for the period (Lucy's traveling ensemble was especially adorable), and the Narnian clothes looked perfectly suitable for a magical land. And the music was always suitable and never intrusive, the way a film's score should be. The locations were perfect, and the indoor Narnia set amazing (if you didn't know that most of the winter scenes were shot on an indoor soundstage, you wouldn't guess).

Although it wasn't part of the book per se, the final battle sequence is nothing short of amazing; Adamson and his band of writers let their creative talents run wild. The Witch in her battle chariot drawn by polar bears is perhaps the most well-known image from this sequence, but it is far from the only thing worth seeing. Be advised, though, the battle is gore-free but intense, and a scene just before it is fairly frightening. Take the PG rating seriously.

My chief complaint: some very important bits were cut or altered. The discussion between Peter and Susan and the Professor seems to skip some things. Also, they never have the discussion about whether Aslan is "safe". The Aslan of the movie never quite seemed to invoke the sense of awe that he was supposed to generate. The movie focussed more on Aslan's humanity (leoninity?) than his role as God-figure, which I suppose was a matter of taste.

Share: X Facebook Reddit Email

Category scores

Directing5
Acting4
Screenplay4
Cinematography5
Music (Score)4
Art Direction4
Costume Design4
Make-Up5
Special Effects5
Editing3

Cast

Liam Neesonas Aslan4
William Moseleyas Peter Pevensie4
Anna Popplewellas Susan Pevensie4
Georgie Henleyas Lucy Pevensie5
Skandar Keynesas Edmund Pevensie4
James McAvoyas Mr. Tumnus4
Ray Winstoneas Mr. Beaver4
Dawn Frenchas Mrs. Beaver4
Rupert Everettas Fox4
James Cosmoas Father Christmas4
Tilda Swintonas The White Witch5
Kiran Shahas Ginarrbrik4
Michael Madsenas Maugrim4
Patrick Kakeas Oreius4
Shane Rangias Otmin4
Jim Broadbentas Professor Kirke4
Elizabeth Hawthorneas Mrs. Macready4
Judy McIntoshas Mrs. Pevensie4

Moments & details

Andrew Adamson in bringing The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to the big screen5
The realism of the computer-generated creatures and armies of Narnia5
The opening bombing-raid scenes in London4
The realization of Lucy meeting Mr. Tumnus on screen5
The addition of the escape on the icy river by Peter, Susan and Lucy5
The realization of meeting Aslan for the first time on screen4
The realization of The Stone Table on screen4
The Battle at the Fords of Beruna5
The resurrection of Aslan5
The final sequence at Cair Paravel4
The Hunt for the White Stag3
The emotional effect of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe5
Rating scale:1 Poor2 Fair3 Good4 Great5 Amazing

Submit your own review