This week has been flying by. I just remembered that it was Thursday, and that I hadn’t written this week’s mailbag. So I’m spending lunch time writing this week’s installment. I spent Tuesday riding roller coasters at Cedar Point, and around that day there were some really huge things happening in the world of Narnia. The third film started shooting, and we’ve gotten some great photos of the Dawn Treader nearing completion. I’ve got a couple of e-mails to answer this week, but before I do, I just wanted to give a status update on the secret project. I’m currently working on speed issues on it, but it’s moving forward. I have guests up from Florida so it’s going to take me a little longer than I had initially anticipated, but I hope that it’s worth the wait.
And a quick update on Chesterton’s The Everlasting Man that just came in from a woman named Barbara: “C.S. Lewis’s appreciation for Chesterton’s The Everlasting Man in correspondence is well known. Tolkien borrowed the idea for Ents from Chesterton’s The Trees of Pride! I hope these facts were brought to your attention.” Thanks Barbara!
Q: Currently, the Chronicles of Narnia are being filmed in the order that corresponds to their publication order. However, Douglas Gresham has expressed interest in filming “The Magician’s Nephew” before “The Horse and His Boy“, instead of vice-versa. What is your opinion on this?
-Skulblaka_Shur’tugal
Paul: This is a great question! I am of the opinion that, when you first read the Chronicles, you always read them in the original publication order. As far as the filming goes, however, wherever they end up shooting The Horse and His Boy, it is the one story that doesn’t really seem to matter when they shoot it. It takes place during the reign of the Pevensie children in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. They could easily shoot it prior to The Magician’s Nephew, but shooting it after could afford them some story things that carry over, giving it more weight in the Narnia film series. This series is made up of books that all take place in the same world, but they are very different from one another in substance. The filmmakers are likely to, as we have seen, invent things that provide more continuity for the sake of the audience. If they did, in fact, shoot them in that order, it would give them an opportunity to introduce something in The Magician’s Nephew that has great weight in The Last Battle and, perhaps, have the Pevensie’s part in the story during The Horse and His Boy revolve around that particular thing, in some way. It would help to make that more of a trilogy, in some ways, and when the films would eventually be viewed in chronological order by super fans like us, we might notice some through lines to the overarching story of Narnia.
But who knows, this is all conjecture that I’m thinking about only seconds before I’m typing it. A stream of consciousness about Narnia filming, I suppose. It’s really quite intriguing to think about the possibilities.
Q: Hi! Somewhere I heard that The Call was nominated for an award. When will we find out if it won it – or do we already know??? Thanks.
-Dyanthius
Paul: I could not find information about this. Does anybody know if The Call by Regina Spektor was nominated for an award? I deserved to be. It was one of the best songs on the soundtrack, if not the best. If you know more information about this, please comment below!
Q: Hey, I was just wondering if you could give me a quick rundown or if you knew any links for a brief overview of what the Invisible Army is about? I’m doing extras work on it and I’d love to know what to expect in August.
-Dee
Paul: Wow, Dee! That’s fantastic that you’re doing some extras work on the film! It’s one of my dreams that you’re fulfilling. Best of luck to you on the film, and I hope that it goes well for you. If you would like to get a great look at what Invisible Army is all about, pick up the book The Voyage of the Dawn Treader or a copy of the audio book. I believe that the audio version is about 3 hours in length. The book itself is not that long and can be read fairly quickly. I will tell you, though: it’s an epic adventure on the high seas, with many locations and troubles along the way. I don’t want to say too much about it, though you can likely find plot synopses all over the web, and you can find chapter summaries here on NarniaFans.com if you look in the book section of the site.
And that’s it for this week’s mailbag! Be sure to send in your questions by using the contact form listed on the menu.
I don’t think The Call was ever nominated for anything, but there were quite a few calls from various websites for it to be nominated for and Oscar or Emmy in 2008.
I don’t think The Call was ever nominated for anything, but there were quite a few calls from various websites for it to be nominated for an Oscar or Emmy in 2008.
Sorry about the multiple postings. I was wondering if anyone could give me a link to where Douglas Gresham said he would like to do Magician’s Nephew before Horse and His Boy. I don’t remember seeing that before. I do know that Andrew Adamson said once he would like to do Magician’s Nephew last, after the Last Battle.
Gresham stated that in one of the behind-the-scenes books for the Narnia films; I believe it was LLW. He also said so in one or two interviews following the release of Prince Caspian.
Thinking strictly of which movies are likely to be successful enough to lead to future movies, the Horse and His Boy is a much, much stronger story than The Magician’s Nephew. (I really can’t imagine reading this one first: its chief charm is as a “backstory” that explains all the mysteries you want answers to, and the awesomeness of seeing the “king of the whole wood” gradually grow to the Great Lion of All Worlds who teleports them to the Wood Between the Worlds.) The more Narnian stories you have under your belt, the more you appreciate TMN, which strictly as a stand-alone story is probably the weakest. Besides, I think most Narnian fans would much rather see Horse, especially given how uncertain the next movie always seems to be.
Budgets will undoubtedly shrink with each movie as well. Horse would benefit from the $ much more than TMN.
The problem is that THaHB is very, very politically incorrect in this age of cowardly Hollywood. I will be stunned if a movie ever gets made of it. Maybe they can take a page from “The Sum of All Fears” and make the Calormenes resemble surviving neo-Nazis.
I recall the The Call was on the long list of songs that could be nominated for an Oscar but did not get enough votes by that section of the Academy to make the nomination list. I think that The Call is the best Narnia song yet.
Ok, here I am… I re-read the article that gave me the idea to ask the question, and here is the link
https://narniafans.com/archives/2727
And reading the comments so far, I guess it was never nominated… It was just on a list that said, “Could be nominated”. I think that’s sad, The Call is a beautiful Narnia song.
Thank you, thank you, thank you for trying to answer my question, I was just reading through the Mailbag and thought, Hmmm, I was wondering about that nomination, too. Then I looked at it and I was like, Oohhh! It’s my question! LOL Thanks!
Hi, it’s been 1 month since I found this marvelous website and I was wondering if any of you guys could tell me how to send questions to be answered – you know the mailbag- I am getting to know more about VDT in this web and I’m fascinated to find a web where currently news on the film are given!
I’d love you help me, how and where can I write my question?
Thanks a lot!!
Laura Elvira
Just click the “Contact Us” link on the menu.
No, I want to see first The Horse and His boy!!!!!
because it is my favorite book of Narnia!!
and I want to see to the oldest Pevensies!!!